Civil Rights Commission

The Civil Rights Commission

Swearing in of the Civil Rights Commission (Notre Dame Archives)

“Civil rights are important corollaries of the great proposition, that every human person is a res sacra, a sacred reality, and as such is entitled to the opportunity of fulfilling those great human potentials with which God has endowed every man.”

 ~Father Hesburgh - Civil Rights Commission Report to Congress

Starting From Scratch

Agreement would be tough due to divisions among Commission members. "With three Democrats, two Republicans, and an Independent, the potential for conflict along political lines appeared to be fairly high.  Eisenhower further complicated matters by dividing the commission equally between Northerners and Southerners."(Father Theodore Hesburgh)

African Americans lined up to register to vote. (SPLC Center) 

Hesburgh and Commission talking to citizens about voting (1962). (Notre Dame Archives).

United States Commission on Civil Rights, opening hearings, Jackson, Mississippi, February 16-20, 1965. (Notre Dame Archives)

A Focus: Voting Rights 

The Commission had 2 years to investigate one specific area of civil rights violations: voting, and then recommend corrections. They started in Montgomery, Alabama, the site of the most complaints.

The resistance from Southern officials made the investigation difficult, but the Commission made their way across the South and North looking at discrimination claims.

"Don't give me any theological stuff, I know what the Bible says, I try to be a Christian, but I'm an old dog." 

- John Battle to Father Hesburgh

Registered Voters in Alabama (Civil Rights Commission Report, 1959)


Hesburgh's Work Through The Hearings

He was firm. 

George Wallace, the circuit-court judge of Montgomery, refused to turn over voting records stating “[t]hey are not going to get the records. And if any agent of the Civil Rights Commission comes down to get them, they will be locked up.” (George Wallace) 

Hesburgh issued a subpoena to get Wallace to turn over the records. "In Montgomery they were telling black Ph.D.s from Tuskegee Intsitute that they could not vote because the rednecks, were not yet "ready" to let them vote." (Theodore Hesburgh, p.182)

The record showed over 1,600 African Americans were denied the vote. The court ordered every African American that was denied be registered immediately. Hesburgh's determination in finding facts showed he would not back down. 

George Wallace, Circuit-Court Judge (PBS.ORG)

He was persuasive.

The Black Belt counties included 16 counties that were 70% - 80% African American, yet not one was registered to vote.  John Battle, a Southerner on the Commission, asked Father Hesburgh for advice.  "Father Ted do you think I ought to speak out strongly on this?" Hesbugh responded, "John your speaking out strongly would mean a lot more than my speaking out strongly.  You're a Southerner, a highly respected Southerner, and they all know that."

Battle later spoke against those trying to slow down the hearings.  "I am a Southerner and I take a dim veiw of intergration of schools and a lot of other things they are talking about up North, but I don't take a dim veiw of voting. Voting is a centeral part of democracy, if citizens have basic intelligance they ought to be able to vote."


John Battle, former governor of Viriginia & Civil Rights Commission Member (PBS.ORG)

He was fierce.

One African American that testified served in the US Army.  Despite his proper documentation, Southerners still stopped him from registering.  When he was done testifying, Hesburgh announced "I want you to go back to that registration place tomorrow morning and tell them that you testified at this hearing.  You tell them that you want them to register you forthwith to vote.  If they don't . . I want you to call me immediately and let me know, because I will then call the President of the United States, who was the top general in the U.S. Army, and I will tell him that one of his officers is being prevented from voting in Louisiana.  I can promise you that the President will make things so hot for everyone . . . that they will wish they had never heard of you." (Hesburgh, p.185) The next day the man was a registered voter.  

Hesburgh with Eisenhower at Notre Dame  (Notre Dame Archives)

Hesbugh Builds a Bridge at Land O, Lakes 

The final hearing was scheduled for Sheveport, Louisiana, but when they arrived, they were told to leave. "You are enjoined by Federal Judge Dawkins's from holding your hearing because the Civil Rights Commission was unconstitutional," a Federal Marshall announced.

There was also no sign the commission could   compromise in writing their report.  Though this seemed like a setback, Hesburgh knew they just needed to build common ground.

Land O'Lakes Retreat (Notre Dame Archives)

The table at Land O'Lakes where they worked on their report.

(Notre Dame Archives)

"It occurred to me that I had the wherewithal to take all my friends on the commission to a far better place, where we could confer without interruptions and get right down to writing our final report" (Hesburgh, p.187). This place was Notre Dame's Research area in Wisconsin known as Land O' Lakes.

What seemed like an impossible task with an "us vs them" mentality became manageable at Land O' Lakes.   Hesburgh felt the first night went well as they connected over a shared love - fishing.​​​​​​​ "The battle-weary Commission  unwound,  relaxed, and made a startling discovery: Every one of the Commissioners, it turned out, was an  ardent fisherman, and the Lord must have been with us . . . because we all caught a lot of fish." (Theodore Hesburgh)The men bonded and fished everyday while talking about the hearings. "When it got too dark to continue fishing together around a big table on a screened in porch. Everyone was feeling very mellow because of the great fishing, the driest martinis, and the great dinner. The staff and I trotted out our 12 recommendations and told the Commissioners we were ready to have them go on them." (Theodore Hesburgh)


Hesburgh fishing at Land O'Lakes

(Notre Dame Archives)