Hunting Rights and Railroads

Hunting Rights and Railroads


After Yellowstone National Park's establishment, Native tribes continued utilizing resources there, like the plentiful food. However, debate sprang up quickly over Natives' hunting rights within borders. Many Euro-Americans believed tribes were opposing everything the park represented by hunting in the park despite these rights being protected by Natives' original treaties. For example, William Manning arrested a tribe of Bannock for violating Wyoming game laws. Similarly, Race Horse, a Bannock leader, turned himself in for breaking game laws, sending him to court. Heard by Judge John Riner, it was decided the original treaties overruled Wyoming game laws, reinstating Natives' rights to hunt within the park. However, about 6 months later, the Supreme Court reversed Judge Riner's decision and overruled the treaties, leading to many tribes' relocation to reservations surrounding Yellowstone. 

A report detailing the progression of the national park ideal 

discusses Congress's decision on Native treaty rights, along with 

the effect of this case.

Ethnic Cleansing and America's Creation of National Parks, Issac Kantor, 2007

"The court found that Congress had, and could, unilaterally terminate the treaty rights in question by admitting Wyoming as a state. The Court noted the creation of Yellowstone in 1872 as an illustration of Congress' authority to nullify hunting rights promised by treaty, a 'remarkable acknowledgment of the intimate link between national parks and native dispossession.'"

Ethnic Cleansing and America's Creation of National Parks by Issac Kantor, 2007

William Manning and a group of 26 discovered a Bannock camp within the park, where they took the tribe's tipis, saddles, horses, rifles, and elk meat before arresting the group, attempting to get the matter to the courts.

William Manning, 1920, WyoHistory.org

Another impact of establishing Yellowstone National Park was tourism. When first established, few people visited due to the difficult location and meager accommodations. However, many railroad companies, like the Northern Pacific Railroad Company (NPR), saw a high-profit opportunity, so they expanded their railroad to reach the park. The NPR extended to Cinnabar, near the northern park entrance, and could now comfortably deliver passengers part of the journey. E.H. Harriman, American financier and railroad magnate, met with people from NPR, discussing the growing tourism at Yellowstone. He ordered a railroad line to the western border, built by the Oregon Short Line Railroad. Building began in late 1905, and by June 1907, over half the construction was finished. The line was completed on November 12, 1907. However, passenger service didn't start until the following spring, the first train arriving June 11, 1908. After passenger service began, visitor numbers skyrocketed for years, until usage of these railroads dropped significantly, the tracks being removed in 1981. The higher number of visitors decreased the Native's rights within the park, as the area became more popular and the desire to preserve it rose.

Northern Pacific Railroad, Wyoming Public Radio

Yellowstone National Park museum curator Miriam Watson explains the journey early tourists at the park took during their stay there.

The History of Transportation with Miriam Watson, National Park Service

"By 1902, Northern Pacific trains reached Gardiner, adjacent to the north entrance to the park. Tourists boarded stagecoaches in Gardiner to continue their trip through the park."

Travel By Train, Museum of the Yellowstone