Short Term Impacts

BREAKING BARRIERS IN HISTORY

Referees missed fewer calls and football had less unfair calls, but as a cause, more plays were reversed because of instant replay. In April 1992 instant replay got banned for four years.

It got banned because it was making the games too long, extending each and every play that needs to be reviewed. This caused the fans all around America to give feedback to ban instant replay. Before Tony came up with the current way of instant replay, it wasn’t “instant”, so he had to innovate it. Another reason is because it wasn’t doing what they were hoping for. Instant replay was clunky and hard to use on each and every play, so they had to keep making it better and more usable in games. This made college football not use it in most games until they could get it to run more smoothly.

YouTube.com, Prime example of Instant replay, December 10, 2010


An official reviewing a play, operations.nfl.com, accessed on 12/17/23

One example is in the 1998 NFC wild card game with the Packers vs. the 49ers. A picture shows that Jerry Rice has the ball but fumbled it before he touched the ground. But the officials said that it was still the 49ers ball. They then proceeded to drive down the field and score a touchdown to win the game. The 49ers proceeded in the playoffs and the Packers went back home.


In the beginning, they attempted to be too accurate with the calls. In a raiders game, the officials wasted five to eight minutes reviewing a fumble call. This happened almost every time in the start of instant replay. The teams that played in the first game that instant replay was used in an NFL regular season game were the Bears against the Browns in 1986. The Browns had a play reviewed using instant replay. This was one of the first times instant replay was used in a regular season NFL game.